Virginity Test – Declared Unconstitutional – Right to Dignity under Article 21 Violated – Request for Virginity Test Rejected – The applicant sought virginity test of the wife alleging her illicit relationship and refusal to cohabit, while the wife alleged impotence – Held: Virginity test is unconstitutional, violates Article 21 guaranteeing right to dignity and perso...
Matrimonial Law - Permanent Alimony – Requirement of Formal Application – Mandatory – The Trial Court awarded permanent alimony to the respondent-wife under Section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act without there being any formal or oral application by the wife – Held: In view of binding precedents of Madhya Pradesh High Court, including Abhishek Parashar v. Neha Parashar, it is...
Limitation – Applicability of Extended Limitation due to COVID-19 – Petition and Appeal held to be within time - Appellant’s original petition filed during the Covid-19 limitation relaxation period as per Supreme Court directions – The Appeal filed within 90 days as provided by Section 28(4) of the Hindu Marriage Act was also within limitation despite Section 19(3) of Famil...
Matrimonial Law - Divorce – Mental Cruelty – Husband's Disinterest in Marital Relationship – Divorce Granted - The wife alleged that the husband was indifferent towards family life, abstained from conjugal relations, and was engrossed in superstitious and spiritual practices – Evidence proved that despite earlier reconciliation, the husband continued neglecting the peti...
Matrimonial Law – 125 CrPC - Maintenance – Interest on Maintenance – Mandatory under Precedent – Review Allowed - The applicants sought review of the judgment dated 29.11.2024 on the ground that the Court failed to apply the binding precedent of Prakash vs. Vithabai, 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 1487, which mandates award of interest on arrears of maintenance – The Court held ...
Matrimonial Law - Divorce – Cruelty – False Allegations Against In-Laws – Suicide Threats – Divorce Decree Upheld – Wife alleged that her father-in-law outraged her modesty without filing any complaint – She also threatened suicide and made attempts to implicate husband and in-laws – Trial Court held these acts amounted to cruelty – Appellate Court c...
Matrimonial Law - Divorce – Allegation of Venereal Disease – No Medical Evidence – Divorce Denied – Appellant alleged that respondent suffered from a communicable venereal disease but failed to provide diagnostic reports or subject her to medical examination – Ayurvedic records held insufficient – Held: Mere suspicion or stigma not enough; strict proof required ...
Matrimonial Law – Recovery of Istridhan - Patrimony and Gold Ornaments – Entrustment Not Proved – Claim Dismissed – Wife alleged entrustment of 50 sovereigns of gold and ₹3 lakhs at the time of marriage – Court found inconsistencies and contradictions in pleadings and oral evidence – Delay of 8 years in raising claim also viewed as improbable – Held: No ...
Criminal Law – Conviction Under Section 498-A IPC Without Specific Charge – Conviction Set Aside – The appellants were initially charged under Section 306 IPC for abetment of suicide but were acquitted of that charge – However, the trial court convicted them under Section 498-A IPC despite the absence of a specific charge – Held: Section 498-A IPC is not a lesser offe...
Matrimonial Law - Interim Maintenance – Financial Independence of Wife – Rejection Justified – The petitioner, a highly qualified woman with a Master’s degree in International Business from the University of Wollongong, Australia, sought interim maintenance under Section 125 of the CrPC – The Family Court denied maintenance, citing her previous employment history, Lin...
